---

In-Depth Review of Alitalia: A Journey Between Italian Elegance and Operational Challenges

---

1. Booking & Website/App Experience with Alitalia

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Official website allows searching codeshare itineraries and Lufthansa/Delta partner flights, making long-haul routes accessible.
• “MilleMiglia” loyalty programme—now inherited by ITA—was well-regarded for accruing miles.

👎 Negatives:

• Multiple complaints about confusing fare bundles and unexpected seat-selection fees. =
• Reviews frequently note opaque baggage fees and unclear allowances—even basic add-ons required at checkout.

---

2. Check‑in Process with Alitalia

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Standard 24–48 h online/mobile check-in—functional and allows seat selection for paid ticket tiers.

👎 Negatives:

• Reports of overstaffed counters with slow service; staff sometimes described as “unmotivated.”
• Gate-side issues: late bag drops and unannounced gate-checking of carry-ons led to stress during boarding.

---

3. Airport Experience for Alitalia

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Rome Fiumicino and Milan Malpensa included lounges for business class and frequent flyers—clean with refreshments.

👎 Negatives:

• Gate areas, especially small domestic hubs, were reported as chaotic and poorly organized.
• Customer service desk interactions were often slow and lacking empathy.

---

4. Punctuality of Alitalia

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Skytrax data praised Alitalia’s on-time performance in early 2019 (top-ranked).
• Some international flights, like Rome–Delhi business class, were noted for perfect punctuality.

👎 Negatives:

• Passenger reviews reported consistent delays—even a one-hour delay on flights meant to be 15 min late.
• Lost luggage also contributed to perceived unreliability.

---

5. In‑flight Comfort & Cleanliness

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Newer aircraft (e.g., A330, 777) presented business class cabins with screens, good food, and comfort.
• Economy seats adequate—industry standard legroom on intercontinentals.

👎 Negatives:

• Several reports of older aircraft with worn seats, inadequate padding, poor ventilation.
• Cabin interiors often felt dated or less maintained compared to competitors.

---

6. In‑flight Services (Crew & Catering)

Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)
👍 Positives:

• Italian meals—lasagna, ravioli, tiramisu—were frequently praised, especially in Business Class.
• Crew members described as “competent, attentive” with high standards, especially on long-haul service.
• Awards: Best Airline Cuisine, Best Business‑Class Seat Design in 2019.

👎 Negatives:

• Inconsistency across flights; some guests found cabin service rushed or inattentive.
• Frequent announcements sometimes overly loud, causing discomfort when using headphones.

---

7. Baggage Handling

Rating: ★★☆☆☆ (2/5)
👎 Negatives:

• Numerous reports of lost or significantly delayed baggage (up to 4 days).
• Some passengers noted damage to luggage and poor resolution/compensation experiences.

---

8. Value for Money

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
👍 Positives:

• Meal inclusion—especially in economy—is a strong value compared to low-cost European airlines.
• Club lounge access and SkyTeam coordination add perceived benefits.

👎 Negatives:

• Unexpected fees for seat selection, baggage, in-flight services could offset appeal.
• Overall score (~2.94/5) suggests limited “recommend” sentiment among customers.

---

9. Overall Experience

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)
Alitalia balanced Italian hospitality and cuisine against systemic operational issues. On some frontiers—especially long-haul service—it delivered strong loyalty qualities (cabin, catering). On others—like check-in hustle, seat condition, baggage mishandling—it fell short. Its performance before becoming ITA ranged from reliable to frustrating depending on route and equipment.

---

Summary Table

Aspect	Rating	Highlights
Booking & Website/App	3/5	All-in-one platform; unclear fees/seat selection required
Check-in Process	3/5	Standard online check-in; slow counters and unmotivated staff
Airport Experience	3/5	Lounge access; chaotic gate areas and poor signage
Punctuality	3/5	Good historic on-time data; passenger-reported delays
In-flight Comfort & Cleanliness	3/5	Comfortable on newer aircraft; dated cabins in older jets
In-flight Services	4/5	Excellent food, especially Italian; crew service varied
Baggage Handling	2/5	Frequent reports of lost/delayed luggage
Value for Money	3/5	Strong food/styling benefits; surprising fees affect price
Overall Experience	3/5	Mixture of elegance and frustration; unpredictable experience

---

Final Verdict of Alitalia

Alitalia offered moments of true Italian charm—from culinary delights to attentive service in premium cabins. However, aging fleet issues, spotty operational reliability, and baggage woes often overshadowed these strengths. If you fly for the experience—especially long-haul—you may enjoy their hospitality. But if punctuality, baggage handling, and modern comfort are vital, consider cautious planning or alternate carriers.

Overall Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)

Recommendation:

• Choose Alitalia for long-haul routes with newer cabins and included meals.
• Travel light, arrive early, and prepare for potential baggage delays.
• Purchase seat selection and baggage early to avoid surprises.

---

Sources:

• TripAdvisor, Reddit, Skytrax, ConsumerAffairs, Wikipedia insights on Alitalia operations, punctuality, fleet, and awards.

---

Note: This review is based on aggregated passenger feedback about Alitalia between 2019–2021 (before being replaced by ITA Airways on 15 Oct 2021). Individual experiences may vary.